Should We Save a Slice for Charters?

Donnie Dicus got me thinking about charter schools in Arizona.  It disgusts me that corporations with absolutely no fidelity to Arizona’s children or communities can profit from money that is desperately needed in the traditional public schools to implement current programs and mandates.

Although I agree with Mr. Dicus’s major arguments against policies that govern charter schools, at least in Arizona, I find myself trying to envision a solution that doesn’t eliminate the promise of charters.  Because I believe there is some promise there.

Donnie brings up an excellent argument for funnelling as much money as possible back into our “traditional” public schools: “If one is broken, invest in it and fix it.” This is a simple and powerful statement, and I agree.  With more resources, public schools could continue and effectively implement an array of good ideas that have been improving schools over the past decades including arts integration, magnet programs, service learning, experiential learning, alternative and blended classrooms, schools within schools, and others, to name a few.

The whole issue is complicated, I believe, by the handful of charters that are actually run by visionary educational professionals who truly want to innovate to provide a quality education and working environment for teachers. City High in Tucson is one example, founded in part by Eve Rifkin, our Stories from School colleague.  Education desperately needs a “sandbox” of innovation– space to innovate and find solutions that our less-than-agile public schools have a hard time doing. Traditional public schools have their hands tied in so many ways that charters do not.

Part of me wants to insist that if we are going to have a charter system, it needs to be held more accountable… as or more accountable than traditional public schools. (For example, why shouldn’t charters have to hire certified teachers? The idea that a teacher at a charter does not legally have to have a certificate is ridiculous.) But then, if charters are held more accountable, will that accountability put a stranglehold on any kind of positive innovation that can happen in these more agile environments? I honestly don’t know.

What if policy could be created to make it harder to get a charter in the first place, that would limit or eliminate the idea of “profit,” and that would somehow create more shared _responsibility_ for children, for quality instruction, and for how the public funds are used? If I felt that most charters shared the same sense of public responsibility that public schools feel (and are held accountable for), I could support some kind of charter system.

I do agree with Mr. Dicus, though. Public school districts have come a long way in terms of innovating alternatives and offering families choices… the issue of family choice is a less-than-convincing argument for charters, and competition does not seem to have improved education. I would also bet that a lot of those profits move out of the state and do not even benefit our economy, which is an irresponsible use of the public funds that are the bulk of our state budget.

What possibilities are there for a functional and fair charter system?


Amethyst Hinton Sainz

I currently teach English Language Development at Rhodes Junior High in Mesa Public Schools. I love seeing the incredible growth in my students and being an advocate for them. I am a National Board Certified Teacher in Adolescent and Young Adult English Language Arts. Before this position I taught high school English in Arizona for 20 years.

My alma maters are Blue Ridge High School and the University of Arizona. My bachelor’s degree in Creative Writing and Philosophy led me toward the College of Education, and I soon realized that the creative challenges of teaching would fuel me throughout my career. My love of language, literature and culture led me to the Bread Loaf School of English at Middlebury College for my masters in English Literature. I am a fellow with the Southern Arizona Writing Project, and that professional development along with, later, the National Board process, has been the most influential and transformative learning for me. I enjoy teaching students across the spectrum of academic ability, and keeping up with new possibilities for technology in education, as well as exploring more topics in STEM.

In recent years, much of my professional development has focused on teacher leadership, but I feel like I am still searching for exactly what that means for me.

I live in Mesa, Arizona with my family. I enjoy them, as well as my vegetable garden, our backyard chickens, our dachshund Roxy, reading, writing, cooking (but not doing dishes), hiking and camping, and travel, among other things.

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

scroll to top